De BBB-rasil para BB+rasil ou o significado do grau de investimento

http://nakedkeynesianism.blogspot.com.br/2015/09/from-bbb-razil-to-bbrazil-or-meaning-of.html?m=1

So Brazil (or here about Petrobras, the State oil company) lost its investment grade status with Standard & Poor’s. You would think this is huge given the media attention in Brazil. If you read S&P’s actual rationale for the downgrading (here) it is essentially about the fiscal situation. They say: “We now expect the general government deficit to rise to an average of 8% of GDP in 2015 and 2016 before declining to 5.9% in 2017, versus 6.1% in 2014. We do not expect a primary fiscal surplus in 2015 or 2016.” They do discuss the political problems too, the corruption investigations,* and the political instability that has plagued the government. There is a discussion of the external vulnerability, but here they are quite sensible and know there is no problem. The report says that: “despite the wider current account deficit, Brazil has low external financing needs compared with its current account receipts and its high level of international reserves compared with some of its peers.” So this is a fiscal problem in their view.
And therein lies the problem. They had years ago also revised the outlook of US debt negatively (my comments here), also on the basis of fiscal, and political, factors. As much as the US then, Brazil now has no risk of not paying its internal debt in domestic currency. And yes, the fiscal outlook has worsened, and the reasons are no secret. It’s austerity. If you cut spending, output falls, and the recession leads to lower revenue and higher deficits. It’s part of the problems caused by policies that S&P’s analysts actually favor. Austerity also is the cause of the recession, and the worsening of the growth outlook in the next couple of years, which are also discussed in S&P’s rationale for the downgrade. So the fiscal problems that are the main cause for the downgrade are self-inflicted wounds (see Serrano and Summa), and the cause of the lack of growth and the worsening of the future fiscal balances.

But more importantly, the downgrade itself is kind of irrelevant. S&P doesn’t think, as I quoted above, that the external situation is particularly problematic. The recession will actually reduce the current account problems, by reducing imports. So there is no external crisis. The devaluation of the real has been part of a global trend, and in part has been reinforced by the government that seems to believe, incorrectly in my view, in the New Developmentalist philosophy that fiscal adjustment (to control inflation) and devaluation (to promote export-led growth) are part of the solution. If the downgrade cannot worsen the external situation, certainly it cannot have an effect on the ability of the government to pay its bills in domestic currency.

At any rate, even if in this case the downgrade is kind of irrelevant, it is important to remember that credit rating agencies were, and still are, one of the worst citizens in international financial markets. They were co-responsible in the bubble, that preceded the crisis, and in the meltdown of the financial sector in the 2008 Global Financial Crisis. The fact that they complain about corruption in Brazil, while they profited giving triple-A ratings to subprime junk is outrageous. And as they say, their views are just opinions. I would add biased and not particularly accurate. They should be put out of business with a public rating agency.

* I could go on on the corruption stuff, but I’ll post something later.

Publicado em Notícias
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • Lava Jato: irregularidades debaixo do tapete 18/09/2017
    Marcelo Auler Ao entender que não há elementos suficientes que provem a materialidade do crime de falsidade ideológica no Inquérito Policial (IPL) 01/2017-COAIN/COGER (autos 5003191-72.2017.404.7000) e […] O post Lava Jato: irregularidades debaixo do tapete apareceu primeiro em Marcelo Auler.
    Marcelo Auler
  • Gilberto Carvalho: “eleições sem Lula, vai ter guerra” 14/09/2017
    Marcelo Auler “Não vamos brincar com esta história de ter eleição no ano que vem sem o Lula. Não vai ser assim. Não pensem eles que […] O post Gilberto Carvalho: “eleições sem Lula, vai ter guerra” apareceu primeiro em Marcelo Auler.
    Marcelo Auler
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • Um novo general Mourão bomba nas redes sociais
    Calma, não há sinais de tropas, tanques e fuzis nas ruas. Mais do que o ataque de um militar da ativa à democracia, o primeiro desde o fim da ditadura em 1985, assustadora foi a repercussão do discurso-bomba do general Antonio Hamilton Martins... Continue lendo
  • Advogado viajou e STF adia decisão sobre prisão de Aécio
    Rodrigo Janot já deixou a Procuradoria-Geral da República e Raquel Dodge foi empossada pelo presidente Michel Temer na manhã desta segunda-feira, mas o STF ainda não julgou os três pedidos de prisão feitos contra o senador Aécio Neves,... Continue lendo
  • Ironia poética: general diz que milicos darão golpe nos golpistas 19/09/2017
    Foi poeticamente irônica a fala do general da ativa que disse em evento reaça em Brasília que "o alto comando das Forças Armadas" planeja dar um golpe militar. Esse recado não foi para o PT, foi para Executivo, Legislativo e Judiciário, que relativizaram o voto popular ao aceitar ou promover o golpe contra Dilma. Agora, os golpistas colhem o fruto […]
    eduguim
  • Na mesa de posse de Raquel Dodge, só Cármen Lúcia não é investigada 19/09/2017
    Via Congresso em Foco em 18/9/2017 Em seu discurso de posse, no qual prometeu firmeza e coragem no combate à corrupção, a nova procuradora-geral da República, Raquel Dodge, dividiu a mesa com três políticos suspeitos do crime que pretende enfrentar: os presidentes da República, Michel Temer (PMDB), da Câmara, Rodrigo Maia (DEM/RJ), e do Senado, […]
    bloglimpinhoecheiroso
  • Essa agora: Geddel diz que sofre ameaça de estupro na Papuda e quer ir pra casa 14/09/2017
    Que Geddel, o homem das malas e caixas com R$ 51 milhões de propina em casa, iria armar alguma para sair da Papuda e ficar em casa numa prisão domiciliar refrigerada a gente já sabia. Mas a desculpa que ele arranjou foi demais:A defesa de Geddel Vieira Lima (PMDB-BA) alegou risco de “estupro” na Penitenciária da Papuda, local em que o ex-ministro está recolh […]
    Antonio Mello
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • This Year's Poverty Data Looks a Lot Different When You Break It Down by Race
    Last week's Census release of data on income, poverty, and health insurance demonstrated two things: There are policies that work for people who are struggling, and there is still a lot of work left to do -- especially for people of color in America. It is encouraging that the people who saw the worst losses in the years since the Great Recession -- spe […]
  • Can Trump Pardon Himself and His Children?
    Was it legal for Ronald Reagan to pardon George Steinbrenner? Was it legal for Richard Nixon to pardon Jimmy Hoffa? Was it legal for Bill Clinton to pardon Patty Hearst? Yes, yes and yes. Yet presidential pardon power is vast, but not limitless. As the Department of Justice makes crystal clear, the presidential pardon power does not extend to crimes that vio […]

Parece que o URL do site WordPress foi configurado incorretamente. Verifique o URL nas configurações do widget.

%d blogueiros gostam disto: