Experiências com a Renda Básica de Cidadania

Some people in the Dutch city of Utrecht might soon get a windfall of extra cash, as part of a daring new experiment with the idea of “basic income.”

Basic income is an unconditional and regular payment meant to provide enough money to cover a person’s basic living cost. In January of 2016, the fourth largest city in the Netherlands and its partner, the University of Utrecht, will create several different regimes for its welfare recipients and test them.

A group of people already receiving welfare will get monthly checks ranging from around €900 ($1,000) for an adult to €1,300 ($1,450) for a couple or family per month. Out of the estimated 300 people participating, a group of at least 50 people will receive the unconditional basic income and won’t be subject to any regulation, so even if they get a job or find another source of income, they will still get their disbursement, explained Nienke Horst, a project manager for the Utrecht city government. There will be three other groups with different levels of rules, and a control group that will follow the current welfare law, with its requirements around job-seeking and qualifying income.

The experiment seeks to challenge the notion that people who receive public money need to be patrolled and punished, said Horst. The traditional criticism of basic income is that it does not incentivize people to work, and thereby damages the economy.

“People say they are not going to try as hard to find a job,” she told Quartz. “We will find out.” Her view, however, is optimistic: “We think that more people will be a little bit happier and find a job anyway,” she said.

Other countries, including India and Malawi, have tested basic income in the past, but the most famous experiment was one carried out in the Canadian town of Dauphin, in Manitoba. Between 1974 and 1979, TheMincome program gave a stipend to the entire population, varying depending on how much money each person earned.

Evelyn L. Forget, an economist at the University of Manitoba, studied this experiment and wrote a report called “The town with no poverty,” published in 2011. Her conclusion? Basic income reduced Dauphin’s poverty and alleviated several other problems.

Although working hours dropped, as skeptics had predicted, it happened mainly among young men, who instead continued their education, and mothers who used the financial freedom to focus on childrearing.

“People thought that it was negative, but men were less likely to drop school, which has an influence in lifetime earnings,” she told Quartz, “and women took longer maternity leaves.”

People who participated in Mincome were less likely to go to hospitals and the town’s health facilities saw a drop in mental-health-related complaints, reducing costs, Forget said.

One substantial difference between Dauphin’s Mincome and the Utrecht experiment, however, is the Canadian program was universal and Utrecht’s will be restricted to those already on welfare.

“What you lose by limiting the program to current welfare recipients is the possibility of making life better for the working poor—people earning low wages in part-time or contractual jobs who sometimes fall between the cracks of the existing system,” said Forget. “When you have a program with more freedom, people have the power to take responsibility for their own decisions and, I think, the outcomes will be beneficial.”

The effect of running a program like Mincome long-term remains unclear—it was ended without any proper evaluation of its results after the Conservative government took over the provincial government in 1977, and the federal government in 1979.

Perhaps Utrecht will offer more insight.

Publicado em Renda de Cidadania
  • Seis meses de reforma trabalhista: um balanço
    Categoria:  Trabalho A reforma tem impactado setores marcados por baixos salários e alta rotatividade. Desde o início, críticos da reforma indicaram seu alto potencial de aumentar a desigualdade Foto: EBC Do Brasil Debate Por Barbara Vallejos Vazquez, Euzebio Jorge Silveira de Sousa e Ana Luíza Matos de Oliveira A reforma trabalhista (Lei 13.467/2017) acaba […]
  • Sem provas contra PT na Transpetro, Moro condena três investigados
    Categoria:  Justiça A prisão do investigado José Antônio de Jesus - Foto: Giuliano Gomes/PR Press    Jornal GGN - Após não achar provas de envolvimento do PT no pagamento de propina de contratos da NM Engenharia com a Transpetro, o juiz Sérgio Moro acabou fechando a investigação e condenou três investigados da 47ª fase da Operação Lava Jato.   O empresário A […]
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • A despedida do Balaio do Kotscho
    Adeus, amigos. Chegou a hora da despedida do Balaio do Kotscho aqui no R7, que publicou meu blog desde 2011. Foram quase seis anos e meio de convívio quase diário, de domingo a domingo (neste último, escrevi sobre o grande Rolando Boldrin, o "Sr.... Continue lendo
  • Última semana para a “reforma política”: eles só querem grana
    Acaba esta semana, no dia 7, o prazo para o Congresso Nacional terminar sua "reforma política" para que as mudanças propostas possam valer já na eleição de 2018. Como os dias úteis das excelências costumam terminar na quinta-feira, o tempo urge... Continue lendo
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.
  • Dez fatos que justificam a CPI da delação, que a velha imprensa quer abortar 25/06/2018
    Joaquim de Carvalho, via DCM em 23/6/2018 A pressão da velha imprensa para que a Câmara dos Deputados não instale a CPI da Delação abre um novo capítulo na história de fracasso do jornalismo brasileiro: agora, os jornais e TVs brigam com a notícia e agem para que fatos obscuros não sejam esclarecidos – ela […]
    bloglimpinhoecheiroso
  • Prisão de Lula é inconstitucional, afirma ministro Marco Aurélio Mello à TV portuguesa RTP 23/06/2018
    Este Blog é mantido exclusivamente por seus assinantes. Assine você também. Apenas R$10 Você pode cancelar a assinatura a qualquer momentoClique aqui e passe a receber notificações do Blog do Mello no seu WhatsAppVocê vai ser direcionado ao seu aplicativo e aí é só enviar e adicionar o número a seus contatos Assine a newsletter do Blog do Mello […]
    Antonio Mello
  • Até a Folha já questiona atuação do Moro 25/06/2018
    Em audiência na semana passada, o juiz Sergio Moro ficou contrariado quando um homem afirmou ter sido intimidado por procuradores da Lava Jato há dois anos. “Essas perguntas, dando voltas, não... Blog de política Brasil. Os amigos do Presidente Lula
    noreply@blogger.com (Helena™)
  • Ocorreu um erro. É provável que o feed esteja indisponível. Tente mais tarde.

Cannot load blog information at this time.

%d blogueiros gostam disto: